Collective apology is not the same thing as collective guilt is not the same thing as collective mandated self-hatred is not the same as individual expressing regret/remorse/apology for wrongs done by the society in which they live regardless of their level of personal complicity in them. And yet many of us, especially those of us in privileged positions tend to engage in the discussion in a way where we're obviously not seeing these distinctions. We talk a lot in these discussions about sitting down, shutting up and listening to what other people have to say; that's good stuff. Sitting down, shutting up and thinking about the nuances of words, however, can also be a big help.
Btw, when I post stuff like this it's because I've been thinking about my own impulses towards defensiveness and seeing the ways in which they don't make sense or aren't fair to other people or actively harm me as well.
no subject
Date: 2010-09-25 01:07 am (UTC)This doesn't even get into the hypocrisy of asking me not to speak in seminar. This doesn't get into being stuck in the same core with two people I couldn't stand two years in a row. This doesn't touch us having to discuss solipsism for the first hour of seminar every seminar the spring of my first year. And on. And on . And on.
The final straw was me looking at my seminar mates two weeks into junior year and knowing what everyone would say before they opened their mouths. It dawned on me that the only class I was actually enjoying was french and the situation was rapidly deteriorating there due to the Proffessor's determination to bed me. I thought about all the upperclassmen I'd known over the years and I realized that, while some of them were cool people, I didn't want to be like that.
I left annapolis in the fall of '90. You?