Changing your Facebook or Twitter icon or participating in a meme is not activism. It can, however, a way to draw attention to an issue. But if you do nothing with that attention, it's wasted. Changing your icon and then posting a status message saying "I changed my icon to support children who are abused" doesn't tell me anything. Include a link to an organization that I can give me time or dollars to. Don't know one? That's okay! Ask people for one in that status message update. All it takes is an extra three seconds to make a potentially meaningless gesture into a potentially meaningful one, just by asking for people who may be more up on the issue to tell you about resources they know about.
Also "repost this if you support gay rights" stuff? Especially stuff that's sort of bullying and implies if you don't repost it you don't support gay rights or whatever the issue is? Fucking obnoxious. My journal, my words, my life. Those memes are honestly upsetting.
And then there are the innuendo-y memes (there's been a few of these to raise breast cancer lately) about "where do you like it," are also annoying. Because they don't connect to the issue, and if the only way we care about women's health is by making innuendos about fucking, we have a problem.
I am not saying don't do memes. Sometimes I change my Twitter icon for stuff too! I am not saying symbolism isn't important -- see: the AIDS ribbon. I am not saying my issues have to be your issues -- we all have different priorities and that's okay too. But I am saying that these gestures without context are the waste of a good opportunity; that only clicking the "like" button doesn't doesn't save lives; that the Internet is a powerful tool for high-impact activism through the accumulation of relatively low-impact gestures in you add a little bit of strategy to the mix.
$$, time, personal testimony, outreach to those in need, political contact are how change happens. Visibility is a tool that makes those things happen. But people aren't mind readers, and if they aren't already energized about your issue, they aren't going to go seeking shit out on their own. They need to be activated, and your innuendo, your snazzy new icon, your "say this or you suck" isn't going to do the job without just a little bit more.
no subject
Date: 2010-12-06 05:02 pm (UTC)Then when you point the slacktivism thing out- you get "wah wah wah, this gets attention for the cause! You're just a big meaniehead."
no subject
Date: 2010-12-06 05:03 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2010-12-06 05:11 pm (UTC)I was sort of hopeful that this would perhaps quiet the guilt trippy Christ in Christmas posts this year, but sadly, it hasn't done that either.
no subject
Date: 2010-12-06 08:20 pm (UTC)Which made me want to barf.
If you want to post "Hey Facebook: Sometimes I like sex!" then just fucking post it. If you want to engage men in the fight against breast cancer [rant about how privileged breast cancer is compared to other cancers deleted for de-rail/length], post something like "Hey gentlemen friends: Ask a woman in your life if you can support her in learning more about how to monitor her health. Promise her you'll do a monthly testicular exam if she'll do a breast exam. Then tell her you'll love and support her no matter what may or may not happen with the health of her breasts." Or whatever the fuck. But don't be all "Sexytimes.... PSYCHE!" Because what are we, twelve?
*cough* Sorry.
Date: 2010-12-06 08:36 pm (UTC)Then, one day I made a really crass, really inappropriate post. It was...ah...sort of along the lines of your "If you want to post "Hey Facebook: Sometimes I like sex!" Only, I'm pretty sure it was the sort of thing you'd see on Failbook as an incredible overshare, followed by, "Wait, weren't we talking about where we like to fuck?!" Because seriously- had it. (I also totally feel your unspoken rant, cervical cancer survivor.)
The tee hee hee cutie poo feel your fucking boobies shit is sickening to me. There, I said it. I hate pink ribbons, I hate the word titties, tatas, I hate suggestive bullshit about such an important issue- mainly because for the love of fucking god the reason we do self exams, the reason we raise awareness is not a matter of sex or aesthetics. Cancer is not cute. It is not an excuse for some idiot to feel me up, or for some other idiot to wear a shirt implying I should be felt up. Cancer doesn't just happen to the nice to look at, nice to touch parts and it sure as hell didn't get discussed nearly as much as people's underpants and sexual activities did as a result of those memes. /rant