Sep. 8th, 2008

Telling me that you know a gay person who likes Palin and that I should therefore calm down about your voting decision that you seem to be waving in my face as some bizarre display of supposed intellectual superiority does not, in any way, make you less obnoxious or less of a bigot. Similarly, bandying about your wild and crazy past does not, in any way, make your casual desire to restrict my freedoms less sinister. And finally, while it may not be personal to you, it's personal to me.

The Republicans keep framing this election in militaristic terms, so let me spell it out for you in words you can understand. You may be in this fight because you like to fight; more power to you. Believe it or not, I really get it. I wish I could be in this fight just for the frivolities of my nature too; might be fun. But I can't.

Elections like this are a fight for my life. And if you think that's hyperbole? Congrats on the luxury.
So there's a bit of a wank going on in the Torchwood community because of an unofficial book that quotes extensively from reviews of episodes fans have posted on LJ. The Author did not seek permission or notify the LJ'ers in question that he would be quoting them.

In addition to the expected discussion on LJ of the legality of this, netiquette, what actually constitutes criticism and the quality of the book itself, the discussion has also ranged quite far off LJ and become colored with some sexism that I find astoundingly unappealing, includng a snarky assertion about how LJ has become a safe space for many women.

Yeah, because that's what TW fandom looks like to me. Buh what?

Seriously, HP had its wanks, but it also was a predominantly female fandom and its dramas had, other than the Lexicon case which was also decided today (and which I will not be addressing) its dramas largely had a very different tone.

Torchwood isn't a predominantly female fandom. Doctor Who _really_ isn't. And this is going to be very interesting -- not just this specific situation, but this first foray into what has been a rather inevitable meeting between different fannish cultures deeply invested in the same media property.

http://rivier.livejournal.com/619067.html

February 2021

S M T W T F S
 123456
789 10111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28      

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Aug. 19th, 2025 03:33 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios