quick CoE sundries

[rm]

I watched CoE again, this time with a group. I loved it even more. Eventually I'll watch it again, with just good friends or alone and wallow again, but today it was fun, and I got to look at it more critically and really enjoy it. I think it's good TV, although with some structural and plot issues. I think the performances were amazing. And most importantly, for my own feelings about it all, I no longer thing Ianto would be ashamed of the choices Jack eventually had to make -- but they would be very hard for him, what with his issues with his own father, Interesting shit.

Also interestnig shit? If you do a rewatch -- pay attention to the color themes on people's clothes -- they shift with aliances and group by family. I am not even kidding. It's GREAT.

Also, that cut on Ianto's face? Through all of at least one episode the cut and small trickle of blood form a lambda. For realz.

I've ranted about the bad behavior going on in this fandom towards creators right now before, but after the things I was told tonight, I feel like I need to say it again. Death threats? To BBC Wales? REALLY?

Look, art is not a democracy.

In fact, all stories start alone. And I say this as someone who writes collaboratively a lot. But all stories start alone. One voice, and then another and another - -whether these be the writers or the chracters of both. And then the story grows. But all stories start as an impulse that needs expression more than the silence and the dark.

When we play in fandom, we too are adding to the story. But stories are not a democracy, rather they are trees as well as shards and fragments. The idea that the fans should have a say in the creation of an original story someone or some team is creating sincerely appalls me. Because art is not a democracy and stories demand their space from the dark.

You don't have to like the stories that come forth. Don't have to play with them. Should be a critic and can completely toss out any canon you want. But those are your stories speaking out, and they don't have to be and shouldn't be anyone else's.

In fencing I learned all sorts of things, like that idea that everyone dies alone and everyone fights alone and everyone lives alone. It sounds bleak at first, but it's not. It's power. It's fact. It's simplicity. I learned the simplest thing is the hardest thing is the best thing. I learned that stories come to us alone.

I'm not saying you have to have liked the many turns CoE took, hell you can loathe it. I really do not care. But never, ever say that people don't have a right to tell their stories and never ever seek or threaten to silence those stories.

I am sad and I'm appalled and because I MAKE STUFF TOO (and to be clear, I don't just mean in a fannish capacity, but as a pro), I do find this personally problematic.

If you haven't seen James Moran's most recent blog post, you should: http://jamesmoran.blogspot.com/2009/07/stepping-back.html.

Also in Whoniverse news that some of you will care about, apparently GDL's one con appearance in the States for the rest of 2009 will be at Hurricaine Who.

Comments

[dancingbarefoot.livejournal.com]

Apparently the insane portion of fandom has taken it upon themselves to do the nutcase tango and it's more than likely going to shoot the rest of the fandom in the foot.

Seen that in about 3 other fandoms that i've enjoyed over the years. The luxury of fanfic writing is that ultimately you can create what you feel was missing in the other's writing. You get the choice to layer onto what exists and who knows, you just may find readers agreeing and adding onto that layer you did.

I have a friend on my friendslist who wrote in a bigbang for another fandom and had a similar complaint, the artist who was going to create the photo for her story began to tear the work apart, trying to get the writer to change around the whole piece (which sounds lovely btw)

Everything begins with an idea like you said and all we as readers or viewers have is the right to enjoy and ask questions of what we see. It doesnt give us the right to become morons. Its better to sit and try quiet protests to show feelings rather than become hooligans and destroy everything in the process.