[ETA: Okay, before anyone else rants at me about dueling -- yes, I know that was a shitty solution too, as traditions of honor were largely used as ways to provoke fights and skill at violence often won out over who was actually correct. Please remember that I'm a student of classical and historical fencing, and that sometimes I'm slightly wry about it. Historically speaking, if one calls "you're a liar" it had to be dealt with, as, at minimum, someone trying to start a fight -- this is my point. Today it's just dealt with as a somehow reasonable part of the political discourse.]
[ETA2: I am not misquoting Heinlein. I am repeating a remark that has often been the subject of discussion in my fencing salle.]
Re: It worked for the Salem Witch Trials, why not now?
Date: 2009-09-10 10:03 pm (UTC)But the saner people didn't prevail at first. Over 150 people were arrested and imprisoned, 20 people executed, and 5 died in jail. For a little while all that screaming and carrying on distracted people and innocent people lost lives and property.
Yes, some of them or their heirs eventually received monetary restitution, 10 years or more after the fact. Some of the accused weren't fully exonerated until 1957, 355 years after the trials.
So, even though most of the people who were accused of witchcraft during 1692-3 in Mass. colony were found not guilty in jury trials, the screaming and carrying on still worked in the beginning.
Re: It worked for the Salem Witch Trials, why not now?
Date: 2009-09-10 10:50 pm (UTC)In this case, the yelling and the screaming has the objective of making the Democrats not to be in power, and it's been going on for some time now. It's getting worse because it's clearly not working, and so of course they have to do it more.
I suppose the beginning of the yelling and screaming was in 2004, so it did work. But not in 2006, not in 2008. What they really can't come to grips with is that people voted for the non-White Guy. They can't cope with that, so it didn't happen.
There's going to be a lot more yelling and screaming, but it's not working. I just wish that the Democrats acted like they understood that.