Some people I know have received some horrifically bad news. I am sad.
Meanwhile, I'm still behind on my NaNo quota, but I wrote another great chapter yesterday and started another chapter that I really need to finish today, although I am not sure when.
That Seventeen article was problematic on several levels.
It smacked of transphobia, and it was lacking a trans POV.
That said, I felt like the telling of the tale and the framing of it were two different opinions. The "author" seemed more upset over the fact she felt she'd been lied to, and worse, the way she found out. The way the article was written, and the way it was framed in the layout was all OMG HE WAS REALLY A SHE HOW AWFUL.
I feel like the disclosure discussion is one I am ill-equipped to make. I know it's something I would like to know, but I'm also not going to proscribe what's right or good for the trans community. Even in the comments at PHB, there was disagreement amongst the trans commenters about it.
To me the issue with the article isn't about disclosure at all. It's that the article refused to accept the existence of trans identity and implied that the act of existing as a trans person was an act of lying as opposed to maybe this particular relationship issue was or wasn't handled well.
Hand to heart, I don't think the disclosure thing is something that will ever be easy in our generation. I know I tend to lead with it on dating sites, and I don't really make a secret of my trans status, but I can think of instances where it was not going to be the first thing out of my mouth for eleventy-billion reasons, one of which has absolutely been the desire to shag or date. The hope is always that someone will see me first, and then accept (and even, holy crap, totally dig?) my hybrid anatomy on account of the rest of the awesome.
But damn, the lying liar narrative is such a huge presence in our culture. And the "but you're really a..." thing. Seventeen need to back the fuck up and run a real, actual, not-sensationalized article on this stuff. This is not okay.
no subject
Date: 2009-11-04 04:53 pm (UTC)It smacked of transphobia, and it was lacking a trans POV.
That said, I felt like the telling of the tale and the framing of it were two different opinions. The "author" seemed more upset over the fact she felt she'd been lied to, and worse, the way she found out. The way the article was written, and the way it was framed in the layout was all OMG HE WAS REALLY A SHE HOW AWFUL.
I feel like the disclosure discussion is one I am ill-equipped to make. I know it's something I would like to know, but I'm also not going to proscribe what's right or good for the trans community. Even in the comments at PHB, there was disagreement amongst the trans commenters about it.
no subject
Date: 2009-11-04 04:55 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-11-04 04:57 pm (UTC)Thank you for clarifying it.
no subject
Date: 2009-11-04 04:57 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-11-04 07:05 pm (UTC)I like to consider myself the "Green Eggs and Ham" on the social/sexual buffet.
Date: 2009-11-04 05:15 pm (UTC)But damn, the lying liar narrative is such a huge presence in our culture. And the "but you're really a..." thing. Seventeen need to back the fuck up and run a real, actual, not-sensationalized article on this stuff. This is not okay.