Anyway, aside from that... Kal Penn in another thankless Whedon role! And I loved, loved that mess of a situation with Gunn's old crew and the karaoke bar and the demon murders and Angel and Wesley and just -- THIS IS MY SORT OF TV. But yeah, it's dark, and it hurts and nobody wins, and I'm not sure how I'm going to feel about what's clearly going to be the endless murky miserable grind of this season.
Now, because I can't talk about Angel without talking about Torchwood: Wesley pretty much has all of Ianto and Jack's best as well as most brutal qualities. I can't look away. I mean, I really, really can't look away.
no subject
Date: 2010-05-15 12:20 am (UTC)1. He provided a CDL , and told them what his SSN is. This is all he provided as per every story I have found. Specifically his wife said she had to bring his social security card along with the birth certificate. He did not have the card on him.
Ok, first off - and this is a sore spot for me - the SSN is not, nor was it ever intended to be a form of ID. It says so on the card. Yada yadda you cant get a cell phone / loan / etc without it. I know all wrong stuff. Still he did not have the card on him and he just told them what his SSN is. anyone could make up a number, or give a name that matches the number. This does not count as ID.
His CDL should have been enough - as per Arizona state law you must have a drivers license of some kind in order to be issued an Arizona CDL. ( http://www.dot.state.az.us/mvd/faqs/scripts/FAQsResponse.asp?Category=4 ). So why did he not have that license with him?
On the other hand, from the sample I looked at , the Arizona CDL has a photograph on it. I know that as per the not enacted yet new law , a drivers license is supposed to be prima face proof of citizenship , but I did not see anything about a CDL.
So what it looks like to me is insufficient ID, and the incorrect expectation that being able to recite ones SSN is good enough to prove who are who you say you are.
Failing to have any other proof of ID on you , the birth certificate is the next best thing. I have to dig through boxes of stuff for mine this week because I'm required to show it for employment. It's nothing special. I had to show it when I had my drivers license flipped too - which is most likely why a drivers license is considered proof of citizenship.
I think it's a little hasty to scream racism, and profiling just yet. I'm not saying that is was absolutely not a factor at all, nor am I saying its not a possibility - but I think that it's too soon to start declaring that all it was was racial profiling and nothing else. I'm sure that there is more to this story than what is being handed out by both sides - as teh state is being tight lipped while they investigate. What I find suspect is that they did not talk about any paperwork relating to the vehicle he was driving - registration , insurance, etc.
this is in the front of my mind recently as I am applying for new jobs and have to go through quite a bit of paperwork and ID hoops myself right now.
no subject
Date: 2010-05-15 05:04 pm (UTC)What do people do in Arizona who aren't citizens but are in the country legally. Students on student Visa's, workers here in H1-B Visas and the rest? Is there a separate license for them?
no subject
Date: 2010-05-15 06:52 pm (UTC)I believe there is a separate license for visitors/people on visas, etc. It's not issued by the state , but more like a passport. International drivers license or some such. I'll have to look into that, I'm not sure.